1. Careers
Send to a Friend via Email

Discuss in my forum

Readers Respond: Should Army Basic Training Recruits be Allowed to use Cell Phones?

Responses: 228

By

There is no right answer

Anyone who sais no, is playing a game not to win but keep the other team from winning and has no clue what our soldier's loved ones go through to help ensure that any given soldier will have the best chance of success in anything they persue. Anyone that says yes, to a degree, is speaking as a civillian should. Civillians are holding down the fort back home and where man kind is accustomed to maintaining a continuous growing relationship or completelly severing all ties, it's a new experience for almost all parties to maintain an environment and atmosphere that can survive without making it difficult for their soldier to come back to. On the other hand, taking away all communication aspecially at times when family and friends come together to celebrate what they helped build together, is de-humanizing to try and sever bonds that by definition, make us human. If anyone has a solid explanation that proves I am wrong that is not an opinion, then enlighten me.
—Guest Someone experiencing this problem.

Yes

In basic training we were aloud to use are cell phones every weekend
—Guest Everett.g.h

No, and not because it's "hardcore."

To all the people saying yes because, "I need to be able to talk to my loved one, this is difficult not being able to talk to them." Or, "this is a new time/era." What in the WORLD did you think Basic Training was SUPPOSED to be? It's not supposed to be easy. It's supposed to be hard, it's SUPPOSED to push you to your limit, break you and, in the end, build you up again. And don't feed me that shit that, "it's not like they'd get to use them often." How often do YOU use your cell phone? If you were in school any time since cells became common place, how OFTEN did you send a text in class? How DISTRACTING was its use? The defining argument here seems to be "it's not like they'd be distracting" and conversely "it's a new time and a new era and we use cells a lot in our everyday life." With that mind set, since we're so socially dependent on them, what in the world makes people think they WON'T be distracting? Deal with it. It's mean to be as much a test of mental fiber as physical.
—Guest Future USAF

Only sometimes!

I think they should be allowed a few mins once a week just to check in with loved ones! my boyfriend just left to train two days ago and i miss him like crazy! i just wanna tell him i love him and miss him alot.. im not asking for an hour long convo.. yes i understand you need to be tough for training but c'mon its like writing letters! its communication!
—Guest army girlfriend

chris

Absolutely. I also think that it each soldier should know before he or she leaves whether or not they can have their phone. Its rediculous that it is a wait and see game. You hear stories before you leave that if you bring it, you might never see it again. I believe that the soldier and the family back home need a connection at least once a week. As a single mom, this is the longest I have gone (4 weeks) w/o speaking to my son who is doing osut (14 weeks). It is very hard, I am sure he misses home. Phone cards are a joke---have you ever looked at the back of one of them---they deduct up to 35 mins. for using the card at a pay phone. Way to support our soldiers AT&T. If you're lucky enough to be able to go to a commissary, you can buy an AT&T card there that "ONLY" deducts 14 mins per call. Fortunately, I was able to go to a base with my other active duty son and buy the cards there to send to my son at Ft. Benning.
—twinarmysons

Hell No!

I do not think they should be allowed to have their phones it is basic training not summer camp. If our military gets to soft our country will no longer be free. The military is not for the soft minded if you can not live without your phone maybe you shouldn't sign up. No one is no longer forced into the military so therefore know what your signing up for before you sign the papers.
—Guest random person

Old times exaggerate

Cell phones should be permitted in bct. Their is nothing wrong on sunday which is their day to relax to be able to use a phone. All of you POG's that just wrote about this have probably used the phone more on a deployment than anyone at bct. Ive deployed twice to afghan and to iraq and ive lived on patrol bases, cop's, fobs and all of those places have phones and you can even purchase a hadji phone on deployment. So it is stupid to say what are you going to do on deployment when you cant call. If anything it will help to push soldiers in bct to work harder during the week in order to earn that privallege. You say BCT is suppose to break you down but you forgot the other part of it, which is to build you up. And soldiers in bct working together to accomplish a misson and being "awarded" with a 15 minute call to family will do nothing bad to a SIT. So YES to cell phones! Sorry old timers, yall are just mad because they werent around then. 7 year 11b still active!!
—Guest 11b

YES

Absolutely! You have family back home. They need support just as much as the person going into the military does! Especially if the one.going to basic has children. Like me!!
—Guest MOTHERof2

Nope

I leave for basic training tomorrow. and i am definately gonna miss my phone and being able to call everyone and talk but it is only for a short time. I was told you get to earn privileges to use a phone(usually pay Phone) so thats better then nothing. plus letters im getting will definately show how many people actually care what im going through and who will be showing support for me. I think it is just fine not having a cell phone.
—Guest Private Colon

YES

YES.I UNDERSTAND ITS BASIC TRAINING BUT FAMILY IS ALL WE HAVE BACK HOME.OUR SUPPORT SYSTEM.ENCOURAGE MENTS , A FEW MINUTES JUST TO CHECK IN WON'T HURT.
—Guest Sammy

ABSOLUTELY!!!

Me and my boyfriend started dating a month ago and our relationship is growing stronger by the day, but tomorrow at 12, he leaves for basic training, 1,040 miles away from me...we are both scared that our relationship will change while he's away but we know that we both want to be with each other, since he has been in my life for about 6 years but we never did anything til' now (just my luck!) but I feel that in order to really make things work, we should ATLEAST be able to get a phone call or a text message a day to keep the relationship strong.
—Guest Military Girlfriend

NOOOOOO

This disenfranchises every other soldier who has been there before. This makes you mentally stronger. It makes the time you have more appreciative. Get a phone when you go to AIT.
—Guest Guest veteran

Dumb

I can see allowing them to use them on Sunday to make a call, but that's it. It's boot camp for crying out loud, not camp cupcake, you signed up for it.
—Guest LT

YES

I dont think that many people here also realize that basic is not just basic anymore for a lot of new recruits... It is a combined OSUT, this is 14 weeks, not just 9 weeks. So, yes, especially in the cases of recruits attending OSUT they SHOULD be allowed a cell phone, at least as a reward. Also, many of you on here went to basic when cell phones did not even exist. I bet if you had a cell phone back then, you would want to be able to phone your spouse, family, significant other, ect. as a reward.
—Guest GUEST

Soldier now coastie

No I like the old school way when one had to sacrifice in order to concentrate more on being a soldier
—Guest Nikita

Why or Why Not?

Should Army Basic Training Recruits be Allowed to use Cell Phones?

Receive a one-time notification when your response is published.

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.